Cases: Consumer Statutes

Consumer Statutes, Section 998: Trial Court Erred In 40.4% Reduction To Prevailing Plaintiffs’ Song-Beverly Fee Request For Fraud Causes Of Action

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Section 998

Language in Defendant’s 998 Offer Was Ambiguous And Did Not Allocate Any Portion Of Payment To Any Cause Of Action Other Than The Song-Beverly Claim. Miss Rose Cade – Queen of the Lemons – 1919 or 1920             In Smart v. Ford Motor Company, Case No. C087422 (3d Dist., January 21, 2020) (unpublished), lemon

Consumer Statutes: Patel Decision Now Published

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Song-Beverly Act Plaintiff Receiving No Damage Award Can Still Be A Prevailing Party, And There Can Be More Than One Prevailing Plaintiff Where Two Plaintiffs Are Involved.             In our December 18, 2019 post, we discussed Patel v. Mercedes-Benz USA, Case No. B293813 (2d Dist., Div. 4), which was unpublished at the time.  The case

Consumer Statutes, Prevailing Party: Abuse Of Discretion Where Trial Court Limited Attorney Fees Award Without Regard To Actual Time Expended By Plaintiffs’ Counsel In Successfully Initiating And Prosecuting Case Under The Song-Beverly Act

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Prevailing Party

Trial Court Erroneously Used Plaintiffs’ Separate Net Monetary Recovery As Basis For Determining Prevailing Party Rather Than Plaintiffs’ Success In Meeting Litigation Objectives.            Patel v. Mercedes-Benz USA, Case No. B293813 (2d Dist., Div. 4 December 17, 2019) (unpublished), includes a nice discussion on prevailing parties under the Song-Beverly Act.             Here,

Consumer Statutes, Reasonableness Of Fees: Morris Lemon Law Fee Decision Now Certified For Publication

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

2 DCA Affirmed Trial Court’s Reduction Of Attorney’s Fees Request In Lemon Law Case For Unnecessary Duplication By Plaintiff’s Attorneys.              On September 17, 2019, we posted on Morris v. Hyundai Motor America, Case No. B290693 (2d Dist., Div. 7 September 16, 2019), which was unpublished at the time.  In that case, a lemon law

Consumer Statutes, Reasonableness Of Fees: Trial Judge Did Not Abuse His Discretion By Awarding $73,864 In Lemon Law Fees Out Of A Requested $191,688.75

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

Case Settled For $85,000, With Duplicative Efforts Properly Justifying Lower Court Reduction And With 2/7 DCA Panel Disagreeing With Another Court That Particular Reduction Articulation Applied Outside Of Civil Rights Context.             Morris v. Hyundai Motor America, Case No. B290693 (2d Dist., Div. 7 Sept. 16, 2019) (unpublished) is a situation where the trial judge

Consumer Statutes, Deeds Of Trust: Third District Agrees That TRO Relief Can Justify Fee Recovery To Prevailing Borrower Under The California Homeowner Bill Of Rights Even If Borrower Loses Later Preliminary Injunction

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust

This Decision Tracks The Reasoning Of The Fifth District In Hardie.             In Bustos v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., Case No. C085657 (3d Dist. Aug. 28, 2019) (partially published), the Third District Court of Appeal agreed that a borrower obtaining a temporary restraining order (TRO) under the California Homeowner Bill of Rights (HBOR) for a

Consumer Statutes: $296,055 Fee Award To Prevailing Lemon Law Vehicle Plaintiff Was Not Disproportionate Or Shocking When Jury Awarded $101,909.52 In Damages

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Trial Judge Did Fashion An Award Less Than The $413,866.50 Fee Request.             Lemon law cases under the Song-Beverly Act can lead to significant fee exposure given a fee-shifting provision liberally interpreted to further the remedial nature of the Act in favor of vehicle purchasers.  That large fee exposure happened here, much to the chagrin

Consumer Statutes: 2/2 DCA Reverses 50% Reduction Of Requested Lodestar Fees To Prevailing Lemon Law Plaintiff Based On Plaintiff’s Rejection Of Informal Settlement Offer

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Defense Should Have Served A CCP §998 Offer As A Mechanism To Curb Requested Fees.             Plaintiff prevailed in a Song-Beverly Act auto case by accepting a settlement offer for $72,000 plus allowing the lower court to determine prevailing party fees to plaintiff.  (The settlement amount was almost twice the amount of the car.)  Earlier,

Consumer Statutes, Multipliers: $327,782.75 Lemon Law Fee Award, Inclusive Of A 1.5 Positive Multiplier, Affirmed On Appeal Where $109,357.05 Was Compensatory Award

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Multipliers

Plaintiff’s Counsel Showed Why Defense Maneuvers And Jury Verdict Made The Case Beyond A Typical Lemon Law Case.             We have said this frequently in the past on prior blogs, but for clients and practitioners defending Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act “lemon law” cases, you need to be attuned to fee exposure, including positive multipliers, when

Consumer Statutes, Lodestar: Lodestar Analysis Governs A Song-Beverly Act Fee Recovery Despite A Contingency Fee Arrangement

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Lodestar

Contingency Fee Arrangement Has Probative Value, But It Is No Dispositive Indicator.             Litigants and their counsel in lemon law cases must keep in mind that the there is an attorney’s fees shifting provision, Civil Code section 1794(d), which allows fees to the prevailing product buyer “based on actual time reasonably expended, determined by the

Scroll to Top