Cases: Consumer Statutes

Consumer Statutes, Reasonableness Of Fees, Section 1717: $284,482.48 Attorney’s Fee/Costs Awards, Allocated Between Two Groups Of Defendants, Affirmed Under Consumer Statutes and Section 1717

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees, Cases: Section 1717

Inadequate Record, Discretionary Apportionment Principles, And Failure To Show Abuse Of Discretion Led To Affirmance Of Awards.             Defendants apparently were shocked by a trial judge awarding a combined $284,482.48 in attorney’s fees and costs against two groups of defendants and in favor of a plaintiff in a case alleging that defendants failed to disclose

Allocation, Consumer Statutes, Lodestar, Multiplier: Although Fraudulent Concealment Compensatory And Punitive Damages Were Reversed, $510,637.87 Fee/Costs Award Under Song-Beverly Act Case Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Allocation, Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Lodestar, Cases: Multipliers

Failure To Apportion/Double Counting Lodestar And Enhancement Arguments Not Supported By The Record.             In many cases, a fees-seeking litigant needs to apportion between fee entitlement and non-fee entitlement claims, unless the thrust of the case involved a fee entitlement case so that it was inextricably intertwined with a non-fee case.  If so, even a

Consumer Statutes: Reversal Of Substantial Punitive Damages Award Required Reversal Of $953,793.90 CLRA/Song-Beverly Act Fee Award

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Compensatory Award Was $72,564.04, Song-Beverly Act Civil Penalties Were $141,973.30, and Punitive Damages Award Was $725,640.40 (After Plaintiff Accepted A Remitted Amount From A $1,451,973.30 Jury Punitive Award).             Margeson v. Ford Motor Co., Case No. B287445 (2d Dist., Div. 5 Sept. 22, 2020) (unpublished) involved a substantial jury verdict and large attorney’s fees award

Consumer Statutes, Prevailing Party: Attorney Fees Of $144,200 Plus Costs Of $5,969.15 Awarded Under Section 1794 To Song-Beverly Plaintiff Affirmed On Appeal Despite Lack of Prevailing Party Ruling

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Prevailing Party

The Trial Court Made An Implied Finding, Which Was Supported By Substantial Evidence, That Plaintiff Obtained His Litigation Objective And Was The Prevailing Party.             Civ. Code § 1794(d) allows a prevailing buyer to recover reasonable attorney fees incurred in connection with the commencement and prosecution of an action under Civ. Code § 1790

Consumer Statutes, Preemption: FTC’s Holder Rule For Consumer Installment Sale Contracts Does Limit Consumer’s Fee Recovery Per FTC Construction

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Preemption

California Civil Code Section 1459.5’s Effort To Repeal Was Preempted By FTC Interpretation.             Lafferty v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 25 Cal.App.5th 398, 410-414 (2018) [reviewed in our July 20, 2018 post] held that a debtor cannot recover damages and attorney’s fees for a Holder Rule claim under a consumer installment sales contract where a

Consumer Statutes: Lemon Law Plaintiff, Only Awarded $2,221.95 In Fees/Costs Out Of $163,205.60, Has Order Reversed Given That She Achieved Triple The Amount Communicated In Informal/Section 998 Offers During The Course Of The Litigation

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Given Substantial Reduction In Lodestar Request, De Novo Review Resulted In A Reversal.             We can definitely tell you that there has been a surge in published and unpublished decisions on the proper standards to be employed in awarding fees under the Song-Beverly Act, commonly known as California’s Lemon Law.  The next unpublished decision joins

Consumer Statutes, Multipliers, Reasonableness Of Fees: Mikhaeilpoor Opinion Now Published

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Multipliers, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

Prevailing Plaintiff’s Request For Fees In A Straightforward Lemon Law Case Was Properly And Significantly Reduced For Overstaffing, Lack Of Efficiency, Excessive Hourly Rates, And Denial Of Lodestar Multiplier.             We discussed the then unpublished case of Mikhaeilpoor v. BMW of North America, LLC, Case No. B293987 (2d Dist., Div. 1 April 1, 2020)

Consumer Statutes: Contingency Agreements Are Not To Be Considered In Establishing the Lodestar For An Award Of Attorney’s Fees Under The Song-Beverly Act

Cases: Consumer Statutes

1/3 DCA Eschews The Idea Plaintiff’s Attorney Would Try A “Double Dip” On Fees, Believing They Would Do The Ethical Thing.             In Reynolds v. Ford Motor Co., Case No. A154811 (1st Dist., Div. 3 Apr. 21, 2020) (published), plaintiff purchased a diesel engine truck from Ford, having the truck repaired 15 times without success. 

Consumer Statutes, Multiplier, Reasonableness Of Fees: Trial Judge In “Uncomplicated” Lemon Law Case Properly Awarded $94,864 In Song-Beverly Act Attorney’s Fees To Prevailing Plaintiff Winning A Jury Verdict Of $35,805.08

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Multipliers, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

Plaintiff Had Sought $344,639 In Fees, Which Lower Court Found To Be Unreasonable Based On Overstaffing, Lack Of Efficiency, And Requesting Hourly Rates Too High For The Complexity Of The Case; Multiplier Request Properly Denied.             We commend everyone to read the appellate court’s affirmance of a trial court’s reduction of an attorney’s fees request

Consumer Statutes, Deeds Of Trust: Third District Affirms Fee Award For Borrower Obtaining TRO Under California Homeowner Bill of Rights Legislation

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust

Fact That Preliminary Injunction Withdrawn Did Not Alter The Result; Its Prior Decision In Bustos Found Persuasive.             In Abdulrahim v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., Case No. C085656 (3d Dist. Mar. 11, 2020) (unpublished), bank reiterated a lot of argument as to why a borrower prevailing under a California Homeowner Bill of Rights TRO should

Scroll to Top