Cases: Appealability

Appealability, Experts, Section 998: 2/8 DCA Declines To Consider Plaintiff’s Arguments Against Trial Court’s PostJudgment Award To Prevailing Defendants Of Section 998 Expert Witness Fees

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Experts, Cases: Section 998

Plaintiff’s Failure To File A Notice Of Appeal On The PostJudgment Award Deprived Appellate Court Of Jurisdiction.             In Nash v. Romano, Case No. B303765 (2d Dist., Div. 8 April 12, 2021) (unpublished), plaintiff tenant sued her landlords after she broke her ankle while stepping on an allegedly unstable backyard paver.  The jury returned […]

Appealability: Defense Side’s Failure To Appeal Fee Award/Amended Judgment, Much Less Include Fee Motion Paperwork In Appellate Record, Doomed Any Challenge On Appeal.

Cases: Appealability

$125,000 Fee Award Challenge Could Not Be Entertained.             In RSF Associates, LLC v. Nieto, Case No. D076227 (4th Dist., Div. 1 Feb. 18, 2021) (unpublished), plaintiff contractor won a $37,222.61 damages award against a landscaper defendant, with the defense cross-complaint recovering nothing.  Later, plaintiff obtained a fees/costs award against defendant of more than $125,000,

Appealability: Failure To Timely Appeal Original Judgment Determining Prevailing Party Or Subsequent Fee Order Fixing Costs Doomed Any Merits Challenge Of Fee Award

Cases: Appealability

As We Have Said Before, Appeal Judgment As Well As Subsequent Fee Order To Be Safe.             This next case from our local Santa Ana court stresses a recommendation we have throughout the years encouraged practitioners to heed:  appeal both a final judgment (the original one, not amended) and a subsequent postjudgment fee order separately. 

Appealability, Discovery, Sanctions: Appeal Of Terminating Sanctions Does Not Necessarily Also Encompass Challenge To Discovery Monetary Sanctions

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Discovery, Cases: Sanctions

2/7 DCA Implicitly Suggests Disagreement With Other Decisions, But Finds Two Sanctions Orders Were Not Intertwined.             OK, for you folks who love technical appealability issues, Taylor v. Forde, Case No. B298957 (2d Dist., Div. 7 Jan. 20, 2021) (unpublished), may be your forte, especially when it comes to appealability of discovery terminating sanctions orders

Appealability, Employment, Intervenors, Prevailing Party, Section 1717: Bevy Of Appealability Issues And Prevailing Party Issues Were Resolved By 4/1 DCA Dispute Between Former Employer And Employee Over Return And Use Of Documents On A Jump Drive

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Employment, Cases: Intervenors, Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Section 1717

Employee Did Prevail On Employer’s Contract Claims, But Lower Court’s Reduced Fee Award For Prevailing On Labor Code Claims Was No Abuse Of Discretion—Given Attorney Intervenors Did Timely Appeal And Contest Merits Based On Their Attorney’s Lien Interest In Fees/Costs Awards.             This next case, Premier Mechanical Group, Inc. v. Harvey (Edwards), Case No. D075663

Appealability, Landlord-Tenant, POOF!: Reversal Of Unlawful Detainer Judgment Against Landlords Required Reversal Of Related Attorney’s Fees/Costs Award

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Landlord/Tenant, Cases: POOF!

In Separate Merits Appeal, Appeal Was Cognizable Although Possession Returned To Landlords During Appeal Because Review Would Determine Landlord Liability For Fees/Costs.             In Lee v. Kotyluk, Case No. G058631 (4th Dist., Div. 3 Jan. 7, 2021) (published), landlords sought to evict a commercial tenant for selling marijuana without a license.  The lower court found

Appealability, Costs: Appeal Of Post-Judgment Order Striking Request For Costs Dismissed On Appeal Against Plaintiffs Who Did Obtain A Merits Reversal Of A Demurrer To A Brown Act Mandate Petition

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Costs

Reason For The Dismissal Was Plaintiffs’ Failure To Adequate Raise Or Brief The Issue.              In New Livable California v. Assn of Bay Area Governments, Case No. A159235 (1st Dist., Div. 3 Dec. 18, 2020 December 18, 2020, published on Jan. 6, 2021), plaintiffs lost a Brown Act writ of mandate petition on a demurrer,

Appeal Sanctions, Appealability: Plaintiff’s Appeal Of Trial Court’s Order Vacating A Default Against Defendant Dismissed, But Defendant’s Request For Appeal Sanctions Of $5,530 For Frivolous Appeal Denied

Cases: Appeal Sanctions, Cases: Appealability

Self-Represented Plaintiff’s Appeal Of A Nonappealable Order Did Not Rise To The Strict Standard For Imposing Sanctions             In Barker v. Di Lando, Case No. A159556 (1st Dist., Div. 2 November 23, 2020) (unpublished), the 1/2 DCA dismissed an appeal filed by a self-represented plaintiff seeking reversal of the trial court’s order vacating default

Appealability, Family Law: Trial Court’s Denial of Wife’s § 2030 Appellate Attorney Fees Reversed And Remanded For Consideration, But Appeal Of Denial Of Her Requested § 271 Sanctions For Appellate Attorney Fees Dismissed

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Family Law

Trial Court Abused Its Discretion By Denying Wife’s Need-Based Fees Request Until Completion Of Litigation, Where Such Request Requires Decision Within 15 Days Of The Hearing That Reflects Consideration Of Statutory Factors, But Trial Court’s Denial Of Requested Sanctions Until Completion Of Litigation Within Its Discretion.             In Marriage of Franecke and Melkonian, Case

Appealability, Homeowner Associations: $180,442 Fees Award, $2,195 Expert Fee Award Under Section 998, And Certain Other Costs Awarded To HOA And Against Homeowner Sustained On Appeal

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Homeowner Associations

Good Pointer On Appealability—Separately Appeal § 998 Shifting Award As a Postjudgment Award, Or Be Damned!             Kashani v. Wilshire House Assn., Case No. B296976 (2d Dist., Div. 1 Oct. 28, 2020) (unpublished) involved a HOA-homeowner dispute involving a right of first refusal battle to bid on a particular condo unit, with the HOA winning

Scroll to Top