Cases: Prevailing Party

Prevailing Party, Probate: $61,557 Fee Award To Removed Trustee For His Attorney’s Work On Trust Petition Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Probate

Trustee and Challenging Beneficiaries Got Mixed Results, So Trustee Entitled To Fees, Inclusive Of “Fees On Fees.”             In Farnocchia v. Harms, Case No. A164639 (1st Dist., Div. 1 Nov. 29, 2023) (unpublished), two beneficiaries of a trust filed a petition to remove Harms as trustee, for an accounting, and for breach of fiduciary duty.  […]

Prevailing Party: Where Defendants Prevailed On Dispositive Motions In Limine And Motion For Judgment On The Pleadings, Dismissal Without Prejudice By Plaintiffs Did Not End The Ability For Any Party To Seek Prevailing Party Fees

Cases: Prevailing Party

Case Involved The Claim That Individual Defendants Were Guarantors Under A Lease.             In Canales v. Superior Court, Case Nos. B321796 et al. (2d Dist., Div. 4 Nov. 16, 2023) (unpublished), on the day of trial, the lower court indicated tentative decisions to grant the defense motions in limine and its own sua sponte motion

Fee Clause Interpretation, Prevailing Party: Where Plaintiff Under An Ejectment Claim Obtained Possession Before Voluntarily Dismissing Complaint, Defendants Could Not Be The Prevailing Parties

Cases: Fee Clause Interpretation, Cases: Prevailing Party

Interpretation Of The Lease Language Led To That Result.              In A & N Industrial Properties, LLC v. Bart & Judy’s Bakery, Inc., Case No. B322730 (2d Dist., Div. 4 Nov. 13, 2023) (unpublished), plaintiff landlord sued a delinquent holdover tenant for breach of contract, common counts, breach of guaranty, and ejectment under a lease

Lodestar, Prevailing Party: Reversal Of Judgment For Cross-Complainant And Increased Recovery For Plaintiffs Made Plaintiffs The Prevailing Party So A Fee Order Remand Was Necessary

Cases: Lodestar, Cases: Prevailing Party

Given Some Reductions For The Cross-Complaint And Other Issues, Fee Award Had To Be Reassessed—Initial Award Was $388,541, A 50% Reduction From The Original Request.             In Perera v. Moine, Case No. B319315 (2d Dist., Div. 7 Sept. 18, 2023) (unpublished), plaintiffs were the prevailing party in a breach of contract dispute (based on an

Homeowner Associations, Prevailing Party: HOA’s $139,977 Attorney’s Fees Award, Made After Homeowners Dismissed Their Lawsuit Without Prejudice And Did Not Pursue Arbitration Before The Case Dismissal, Was Properly Granted

Cases: Homeowner Associations, Cases: Prevailing Party

“Prevailing Party” Definition Under Davis-Stirling Act Different Than Under Civil Code § 1717.             In Matus v. Freedom West Homes Corp., Case No. A165736 (1st Dist., Div. 2 Aug. 21, 2023) (unpublished), a group of homeowner plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against HOA, which was ordered into arbitration.  Plaintiffs dismissed their court case without prejudice 15

Prevailing Party: Cross-Complainant Winning More Than Plaintiff Was The Prevailing Party For Fee Recovery Purposes

Cases: Prevailing Party

Cross-Complainant Obtained An $88,130.06 Net Recovery, Such That A Subsequent $90,013 Prevailing Party Fee Determination Was No Abuse Of Discretion.             In VanLaw Food Products, Inc. v. New England Counry Foods, LLC, Case No. G061375 (4th Dist., Div. 3 July 6, 2023) (unpublished), plaintiff received $27,441.25 under its complaint, and cross-complaint received $115,571.31 on its

Prevailing Party: Tenant’s Successful Demurrer, Resulting In A Dismissal Of A Case Without Prejudice To Refiling A Future Complaint, Did Not Entitle Tenant To Prevailing Party Fees

Cases: Prevailing Party

An Interim Dismissal Without Prejudice Did Not Dispositively Determine Who Prevailed.             Tenant, during the COVID-19 pandemic, successfully demurred to a landlord complaint on the basis that the lawsuit was premature given pandemic rules which did not allow the suit to be filed when it was.  The demurrer was sustained without prejudice to filing a

Costs, Prevailing Party: Party Achieving Partial Success, And Reversal Of Prior Fee Prevailing Party Adverse Against It, Was Not Entitled To Fees On Remand Because Lower Court Properly Determined It Did Not Prevail

Cases: Costs, Cases: Prevailing Party

The Appellate Win Did Not Allow For Prevailing Party Fees, Because The Ultimate Litigation Outcome Result Was Dispositive—No One Prevailed.             The next case, Waterwood Enterprises, LLC v. City of Long Beach, Case No. B316269 (2d Dist., Div. 1 Apr. 26, 2023) (unpublished) had a topsy-turvy procedural history, but it at long last has seemed

Prevailing Party: Where Cross-Complaint Was Dismissed Without Prejudice And Subject To A Tolling Agreement, Trial Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion To Determine There Was No Prevailing Party For A Fee Recovery—As Yet

Cases: Prevailing Party

Costs Prevailing Party Determination Was Not Dispositive As To Fee Prevailing Party Determination.             Davis v. Philpott Meeks, LP, Case No. B316618 (2d Dist., Div. 7 Apr. 17, 2023) (unpublished) was a situation where plaintiff filed an unlawful detainer complaint, generating various cross-complaints for premises liability and indemnity.  Certain cross-claimants dismissed their cross-complaints without prejudice

Arbitration, Prevailing Party: Attorney Fees And Costs Award Of $334,458.41 Affirmed Against Plaintiff Attorney Who Achieved, Under A Confirmed Arbitration Award, A Monetary Recovery Of A Small Bit Of The $3,720 In Fees He Sought From Defendant Client

Cases: Arbitration, Cases: Prevailing Party

The Award Was Governed By The Statutory Fee Provisions Provided For By The Mandatory Fee Arbitration Act, Not The Parties’ Contract Fee Provision.             Under the MFAA (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6200 et seq.), enacted to eliminate bargaining power disparity between attorneys and clients trying to resolve fee disputes, neither party to a

Scroll to Top