Cases: Trade Secrets

Trade Secrets: Failure To Identify Trade Secret With Particularity Meant Plaintiff’s Case Was Baseless, Justifying A Fee Award Of More Than $202,291.50 To Defendant

Cases: Trade Secrets

  Civil Code Section 3426.4 Was the Fee Entitlement Predicate.      Civil Code section 3426.4 allows a prevailing party in a trade secret misappropriation case to obtain a discretionary award of attorney’s fees and costs if the claim is made in bad faith. Case law has clarified that both objective speciousness and subjective bad faith

Settlement/Section 1717/Trade Secret: Court of Appeal Honors Settlement Agreement Procedures Reserving Fee Determination

Cases: Section 1717, Cases: Settlement, Cases: Trade Secrets

Settlement Agreement’s Reservation Of Fee Determination Based on Trade Secret Misappropriation Statute Did Allow Lower Court To Determine If Fee Entitlement Proven In Postjudgment Fee Proceeding Denial of Fee Recovery Reversed and Remanded.      Khavarian Enterprises, Inc. v. Commline, Inc., Case No. B243467 (2d Dist., Div. 4 May 14, 2013) (published) demonstrates that appellate courts

Discovery/Special Fee Shifting Statute/Trade Secrets: Losing Plaintiffs In Patent/Trade Secret Dispute Hit With $12.46 Million For Attorney’s Fees And Electronic Discovery Expenses

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Special Fee Shifting Statutes, Cases: Trade Secrets

  Only $1 Million Reduction From Fees Requested.      Patent/trade secrets are usually vigorously and heavily litigated, and the losers can get hit with substantial fees/expenses as Gabriel Techs., Corp. v. Qualcomm, Inc., Case No. 08CV1992 AJB (MDD), 2013 WL 410103 (S.D.Cal. Feb. 1, 2013) demonstrates.      There, plaintiffs lost a patent infringement/trade secrets case.

Special Fee Shifting Statute/Substantiation of Fees/Trade Secrets: Ninth Circuit Decision Is In — Mattel v. MGA Entertainment Appeal

Cases: Special Fee Shifting Statutes, Cases: Substantiation of Reasonableness of Fees, Cases: Trade Secrets

  Trade Secrets Damages/Fees/Costs Go POOF!, But Copyright Defense Fee/Costs Recovery to MGA Sustained On Appeal.      In a remarkably short decision penned by Chief Justice Kozinski on behalf of a 3-0 panel, the Ninth Circuit has taken some things away and let other things stay in the oft-posted-upon Mattel, Inc. v. MGA Entertainment, Inc.,

Trade Secrets: $39,593.87 Fee Award To Defendant, After Case Voluntarily Dismissed By Plaintiff Without Prejudice, Reversed Under Uniform Trade Secrets Act Case

Cases: Trade Secrets

  Plaintiff’s Case Was Not Objectively Specious, Requiring an Overturn of Fee Award.      Under the Uniform Trade Secrets Act (UTSA), Civil Code section 3426.4 permits a trial court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to a prevailing party if it determines that a UTSA claim has been made in “bad faith,” which has

Trade Secrets: Plaintiff Losing Time-Barred Trade Secrets Misappropriation Claim Suffered Adverse Fee And Costs Awards Totaling Over $311,000

Cases: Trade Secrets

  Defense Set Up Bad Faith By Sending Litigation Communicative Warnings to Loser Which Showed Claim Was Stale.      We have discussed Civil Code section 3426.4 several times. This provision allows a court to discretionarily award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to a prevailing party where a claim of trade secret misappropriation was made in

Trade Secrets: Voluntarily Dismissed Action Did Not Lead to Award Of Attorney’s Fees In Trade Secret Action

Cases: Trade Secrets

  Trial Court Found That Employer Did Not File Action in Bad Faith.      Bad faith trade secret claims allow the court to discretionarily award reasonable fees and costs to the prevailing party, although the claimant has to prove both objective speciousness of the plaintiff’s claim and subjective bad faith in bringing/maintaining the claim. (Civ.

Trade Secrets: Defendant Winning Trade Secret Case Properly Denied Fee Recovery

Cases: Standard of Review, Cases: Trade Secrets

  Trial Court’s Finding of “No Bad Faith” Was Deferred to on Appeal.      For appellate practitioners and litigators contemplating an appeal, you by now should know that most factual findings–even those than can be implied–usually will uphold a judgment or trial court determination. This substantial evidence rule and its close cousin, the abuse of

Scroll to Top