Cases: Consumer Statutes

Consumer Statutes/Section 998: Song-Beverly Warranty Act Acceptor of 998 Offer Garners Significant Attorney Fees and Costs Award

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Section 998

  No Judgment Needed and Dismissal With Prejudice Sufficient to Shift Fees and Costs Under Song-Beverly Act Scheme.      The Fifth District in Wohlgemuth v. Caterpillar, Inc., Case No. F061981 (5th Dist. July 23, 2012) (partially published) answered some interesting questions about the nature of Code of Civil Procedure section 998 fee-shifting in the context

Consumer Statutes/Special Fee Shifting Statutes: Consumer Winning Fraud Case Against Motor Vehicle Retailer Doesn’t Get Fees Under Vehicle Code Statute, Doesn’t Get Fees Under Contractual Provisions Based On Surety Law, But Does Get Them

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Special Fee Shifting Statutes

  Wow–Fee Entitlement Can Be Had, If You Are Tenacious And Can Get to the Right Independent Basis!      The Fifth District’s decision in Pierce v. Western Surety Co., Case No. F062096 (5th Dist. June 22, 2012) (published) goes to show you that the fee entitlement race sometimes goes to the tenacious. All you need

Arbitration/Consumer Statutes: Waiver Of Attorney’s Fees Recovery In Residency Arbitration Provision Was Against Public Policy

Cases: Arbitration, Cases: Consumer Statutes

  Fee-Shifting Provision in Elder Abuse Law Vetted An Important Public Policy.      The Fifth District in Bickel v. Sunrise Assisted Living, Case No. F062443 (5th Dist. May 21, 2012) (certified for publication) involved a plaintiff suing defendant assisted living facility for elder abuse. Plaintiff entered into a residency agreement with an arbitration clause, with

Consumer Statutes/Reasonableness Of Fees: Trial Court Awarding $6,245.54 Of Settling Consumer’s Requested $35,287.46 In Fees Under Consumer Legal Remedies Act Was No Abuse Of Discretion

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

  Lower Court Could Conclude Consumer’s Requested Fees Were Padded in Making Reduced Award.      Plaintiff consumer reached a settlement with Sears, Roebuck for a gift card dispute under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, preserving the ability to seek reasonable fees and costs from the lower court under the compromise. (CLRA does have a fee-shifting

Consumer Statutes/Substantiation Of Fees: Anti-Spam Winning Plaintiff Garners $81,900 In Attorney’s Fees After Winning $7,000 In Liquidated Anti-Spam Damages

Cases: Consumer Statutes

  Fee Substantiation Was Adequate, Where Detail Told the Appellate Court All You Needed to Know.      For all of you Spam lovers (bad pun, because this is really, an Internet Anti-Spam case), this next case will be of interest. Not to mention the derivation of the term “spam” in the email context–we will leave

Consumer Statutes: Appellate Court’s Reinstatement Of Restitutionary Award To Mobilehome Residents Justified $388,759.00 Fee And $39,486.98 Cost Awards

Cases: Consumer Statutes

  Special Mobilehome Residency Law Fee-Shifting Provision Entitled Plaintiffs to Fee/Costs as Prevailing Parties.      Civil Code section 798.85 is a special fee-shifting statute in the Mobilehome Residency Law statutory scheme, mandating an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to the prevailing party under the scheme.   Above:  Palace mobile home.  Washington, D.C.  September

Consumer Statutes/POOF!: Elder Abuse Fee Award Reversed Because 2008 Amendments Not Retroactive

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: POOF!

  $326,588 Award Went Bye-Bye.      Plaintiffs in an elder abuse case where the crucial claims centered about defendants’ undue influence of an elder, causing an amendment to a testamentary trust, fared well in the trial court. The lower court invalidated the trust and awarded plaintiffs attorney’s fees of $326,588 under Welfare & Institutions Code

Consumer (Environmental) Statutes: Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals Affirms $483,073.88 Attorney’s Fees Award Under Clean Air Act

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC Lost Appeal of Adverse Fee Award.      Because Friday was a slow day for decisions on attorney’s fees issues in the California state courts and Ninth Circuit, we instead review a federal appellate decision affirming a substantial fee award under the Clean Air Act.      Under the Clean Air Act’s citizen

Consumer Statutes/Equity: Attorney Denied Appellate Fees For Beating A Client’s Claim Requesting A Refund Of Unearned Fees Based On A Technicality

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Equity

Failure to Award Fees under B & P § 6204(d) Was No Abuse of Discretion.      Here is an interesting case in the continuing saga of prominent civil rights attorney Stephen Yagman. The case is also poignant in showing how trial and appellate courts will use equitable principles to resolve fee recovery matters.      In

CCP Section 998, Costs, And Consumer Fee Shifting Statute: Fee Award To CLRA Settling Plaintiff Affirmed Upon Denial of Defense 473 Motion Relating To 998 Offer Containing No Language Dealing With Fees/Costs

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs, Cases: Section 998

Silent 998 Offer Came Back to Bite the Defense as Silence Proves Golden for Prevailing Party.      Many of the decisions we examine have major object lessons for litigators to pay heed to. After all, we like to say that good case management skills are usually learned through mistakes. This next case illustrates this principle

Scroll to Top