Cases: Consumer Statutes

Consumer Statutes: Winning Plaintiff’s Request For More Attorney’s Fees Rebuffed In Lemon Law Car Case

Cases: Consumer Statutes

$64,000 Attorney’s Fees Sustained on Appeal By Second District, Division 8.      Plaintiff, in a Lemon Law car case, actually won $37,508.84 for breach of implied warranty and $560 for breach of express warranty as against Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC (MB). Because the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act has a mandatory fee shifting provision for winning car

Consumer Statutes: CCP § 1032 "Prevailing Party" Standard Does Not Have To Govern Fee Recovery Under CLRA or ASFA

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Fourth District, Division 3 Rejects Kim‘s Reliance on § 1032 Standard.      In a very interesting case arising out of Orange County litigation, our local Santa Ana appellate court has parted company with another appellate court as far as the "prevailing party" standard to use for fee entitlement purposes under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act

Consumer Statutes: Plaintiff Was Lucky To Get $20,400 In Lemon Law Fees After Rejecting Defense Settlement Offers

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

Fourth District, Division One Reinforces that Consumer Statutes Are Not a Blank Attorney’s Fees Check.      This next one is a lemon law case, arising under the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act with a mandatory fee-shifting provision. However, that fee-shifting statute only allows recovery of reasonable attorney’s fees to the prevailing party (Civ. Code, § 1794(d);

Consumer Arbitrations: Consumer Contract Authorizing Fees Runs Afoul Of CCP § 1284.3 Statutory Protections

Cases: Arbitration, Cases: Consumer Statutes

  Fourth District, Division 1 Reverses Arbitration Fee Award on Public Policy Grounds on Appeal.      Code of Civil Procedure section 1284.3(a) is a pro-consumer arbitration provision that states an arbitrator/neutral cannot administer an arbitration for a consumer in a way that makes the consumer responsible to pay attorney’s fees or costs if he/she is

Consumer Statutes And Section 998: Plaintiff’s Waiver Of Fees In Accepting 998 Offer Binds Plaintiff

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Section 998

Second District, Division 3 Also Finds 998 Fee Waiver In Not Illegal under California’s Lemon Law.      The next case, involving the interplay between Code of Civil Procedure section 998 pretrial offers and California consumer/civil fee shifting statutes, basically holds plaintiff to the bargain reached when he accepted the 998 offer made by defendants.     

Non-Taxable Federal Costs: District Courts Can Award Non-Taxable Costs Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs, Cases: Special Fee Shifting Statutes

Ninth Circuit So Holds in 2-1 Decision; Dissent Thinks Majority Decision Allows Recovery of Non-Taxable Costs as Attorney’s Fees in Most Fee-Shifting Statutes.      The next case is an interesting one, provoking a 2-1 decision on an important issue: when are non-taxable costs awardable as attorney’s fees under federal fee-shifting statutes. The question did not

Fair Debt Collection Practices Act Costs: Prevailing Defendant Cannot Be Awarded Costs Unless The Plaintiff Brought The Action In Bad Faith And For Harassment Purposes

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs

$6,511.46 Costs Award Against Plaintiff Reversed, Because Bad Faith/Harassment Is Necessary Predicate For Adverse Costs Award in Favor of Prevailing Defendant.      In Rouse v. Law Offices of Rory Clark, Case No. 09-55146 (9th Cir. May 3, 2010) (for publication), a district judge awarded $6,511.46 in routine costs to a prevailing defendant in a Fair

Lemon Law: $170,000 Attorney Fee Recovery Sustained In Song-Beverly Act Case Involving Mobilehome

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Lodestar, Cases: Multipliers, Cases: Substantiation of Reasonableness of Fees

Fourth District, Division 1 Sustains Lower Court Determination Based on Its Experience With Hourly Rates.      In Cauchon v. Forest River, Inc., Case Nos. D053864/D054433 (4th Dist., Div. 1 Apr. 9, 2010) (unpublished), mobilehome purchasers did well in a Song-Beverly Act Warranty Act suit with a mandatory fee-shifting statute in favor of prevailing plaintiffs. Purchasers

Scroll to Top