Cases: Consumer Statutes

December 17, 2015 Unpublished Fee Decisions—Three Reversals, Two Affirmances On Variety Of Issues

Cases: Allocation, Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs, Cases: Family Law, Cases: Settlement

  Allocation—Artefex LP v. Bushman, Case No. B260737 (2d Dist., Div. 6 Dec. 17, 2015) (Unpublished).     In this one, plaintiffs won $15,000 on a contract breach claim after voluntarily dismissing tort claims, with the trial judge then awarding $191,256 in fees and $11,778.37 in costs based on a fees clause.  The 2/6 DCA reversed

Consumer Statutes/Reasonableness Of Fees: $60,000 Lemon Law Fee Recovery, Out Of Requested $119,862, Affirmed On Appeal.

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

  Challenge To Reasonableness Of Hourly Rate And Work Performed Rebuffed.      California’s Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act (sometimes dubbed a “lemon law” in car/RV cases) has a fee-shifting provision which requires the trial court to engage in a little bit different analysis, but not really that different under the lodestar method: determine the actual time

Consumer Statutes, Costs, Section 998: Plaintiff Losing Consumer Legal Remedies Act Claim Properly Exposed To Costs, Expert Witness Fees, And Attorney’s Fees

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs, Cases: Section 998

  No Costs Allocation Between Plaintiffs Required, 998 Offer Shifted Expert Witness Fees, And Prosecution Of CLRA Claim At Trial Was Not In Good Faith.     Foss v. San Antonio Community Hospital, Case No. E057236 (4th Dist., Div. 2 July 28, 2015) (unpublished) was a case prosecuted by plaintiffs against medically affiliated defendants under various

Consumer Statutes, Section 998: Trial Judge Erroneously Denied Prevailing “Lemon Law” Consumer Fees Incurred For Subsequent Work Occurring After Consumer Rejected Initial Settlement Offer And For “Fees On Fees” Work

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Section 998

  Car Manufacturer’s First And Second Offers Were Different, And “Fees On Fees” Are Recoverable For Fee Motion Work Under Lemon Law Fee Shifting Provision.      California’s “lemon law” has a fee-shifting provision in favor of a prevailing consumer buyer. (Civ. Code, § 1794(d).) Actual time is recoverable under this provision, as long as it

Consumer Statutes, Deeds of Trust: Borrower Obtaining Preliminary Injunction Under “Dual Tracking” Prohibition Fee Shifting Statute Erroneously Denied Fees

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust

  Civil Code Section 2924.12(i) Did Allow Fee Entitlement.      In response to the residential subprime meltdown, the California Legislature prohibited “dual tracking,” namely, recording a notice of trustee’s sale while simultaneously engaging in a loan modification process, with injunctive and damages relief being allowed depending on when the trustee’s sale notice was recorded. Injunctive

Consumer Statutes, Prevailing Party, Private Attorney General: Plaintiff Losing Unfair Competition Law and Consumer Legal Remedies Act Claims Properly Denied Fee Request Of $337,443

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Private Attorney General (CCP 1021.5)

  Plaintiff Was Not Successful and Defendant Fixed Problem Based on CLRA Pre-Suit Notice.      In Boling v. DTG Operations, Inc., Case No. G049360 (4th Dist., Div. 3 Mar. 2, 2015) (unpublished), plaintiff sued under the Unfair Competition Law (UCL) and Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) to recover damages for a small discrepancy between a

Consumer Statutes, Costs, Prevailing Party, Section 998: Car Plaintiff In Song-Beverly/Magnuson-Moss Dispute Properly Denied Fees But Entitled To Costs

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs, Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Section 998

  Car Manufacturer Defendant Prevailed For Fees, But Might Be Liable For Some Routine Costs.      Actually, we can say that counsel for Mercedes-Benz in this case made some good moves as far as mitigating fee/costs exposure. M-B was embroiled in a gripe from a car owner about excessive multiple repairs. Car owner sued, but

Consumer Statutes/Lodestar/Reasonableness Of Fees: Ford’s Oral Opposition To Lemon Law Fee Request Was Unsuccessful As Was Subsequent Appeal

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Lodestar, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

  Ford Motor Hit With $50,574.19 Lemon Law Jury Verdict, And Then Hit Again With $342,540.25 In Fees As Well As Costs/Expenses On Top.      Many California consumer statutes, like the lemon laws, have mandatory fee-shifting statutes. Frequently, a winning plaintiff can obtain fee awards that are many times a multiplier of the underlying merits

Scroll to Top