Cases: Consumer Statutes

Consumer Statutes/Costs:  2/2 DCA In Unpublished Decision Has Great Review Of Routine Costs Rules

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Costs

Appellate Court Also Has Specific Discussion On Reasonable Photocopy Expenses, PowerPoint Technician Costs, And Court Reporter Fee Charges             We have to say that the 2/2 DCA’s unpublished decision in Haroun v. BMW of North America, LLC, Case No. B272279 (2d Dist., Div. 2 Sept. 5, 2017) (unpublished) has a great discussion of general routine

Consumer Statutes: Third District Decides Broad Interpretation Of Remedial Swimming Pool Construction Statute Should Not Be Adopted And That Plaintiff Did Not Prevail

Cases: Consumer Statutes

We Explore This Decision’s Reasoning In Our Comment.                                                                                                  Movie:  The Drowning Pool.  1975.              In El Dorado Custom Pools v. Stein, Case No. C075500 (3d Dist. July 10, 2017), a plaintiff contracted with a pool company to built a pool on his property.  Pool company sued for breach of contract, quantum meruit and other

Consumer Statutes: Potentially Prevailing Plaintiff On Appeal May Have Entitlement To Fee Recovery Under CLRA Where Only Sought Injunctive Relief Despite Rejecting Defense Correction Notice

Cases: Consumer Statutes

Plaintiff Is Not Disqualified From Fee Recovery Given Only Injunctive Relief Requested Under CLRA Claim; Matter Remanded For District Court To Determine Prevailing Party Status.     Gonzales v. CarMax Auto Superstores, No. 14-56305 (9th Cir. Jan. 6, 2017) (published) involved a situation where a plaintiff won a summary judgment and sustained it on appeal in

Allocation/Consumer Statutes: Prevailing Dealer In BMW Dispute Properly Awarded 30% Of Requested Fees Based On Dealer’s Own Allocation

Cases: Allocation, Cases: Consumer Statutes

  Dealer Did A Smart Thing Here In Apportioning Fees Between Claims.    Tun v. Wells Fargo Dealer Services, Case No. D070447 (4th Dist., Div. 1 Nov. 7, 2016) (published) is a nice illustration of a smart move that a prevailing party undertook under a fee-shifting statute in its fee petition papers.  That move was

Consumer Statutes: Successfully Settling Plaintiff Sustains Lower Court Win Of Over $180,000 In Attorney’s Fees Under The Song-Beverly Act In Lemon Law Case

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

  Defense Prior Efforts To Settle Contained Unreasonable Extraneous Terms And Case Was Hard Fought, Justifying A $575 Hourly Lodestar Rate.      When you try to settle a case, make sure you do not ask for extraneous extractions of an unreasonable or unallowable nature. The failure to do so doomed the defense efforts to challenge

Appealability, Consumer Statutes, Deeds Of Trust: Third District’s Sese Decision Now Published

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust

  Dealt With Appealability Of Denial Of Fee Award To Plaintiff Winning Preliminary Injunction Under California Homeowner Bill Of Rights.     In our post of July 30, 2016, we discussed the unpublished decision in Sese v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., which ruled that a plaintiff winning a preliminary injunction under the California Homeowner Bill of

Appealability, Consumer Statutes, Deeds Of Trust: Borrower’s Appeal of Trial Court’s Denial Of Fees To Borrower Winning Preliminary Injunction Under California Homeowner Bill Of Rights Was Dismissed

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust

  Borrower Appealed From A Nonappealable Interlocutory Order.      In Monterossa v. Superior Court, 237 Cal.App.4th 747, 751 (2015) [discussed in our June 14, 2015 post], the Third District decided that a borrower obtaining preliminary, rather permanent, injunctive relief under the California Homeowner Bill of Rights may be entitled to an award of attorney’s fees

Consumer Statutes: Lawyer Losing Debt Collection Claims Against Chiropractor Not Liable For Attorney’s Fees Because His Claims Were Not Brought In Bad Faith

Cases: Consumer Statutes

  All Of The Consumer Statutes Required Bad Faith, Found Not To Exist And Affirmed Under Appellate Abuse Of Discretion Standard.       Above:  chiropractic adjustment of horse.  Wikpedia.  Photographer:  Dr. Dennis Eschbach.  Wikipedia Creative Commons License.      In Libman v. Bondarev Chiropractic, Inc., Case No. B259498 (2d Dist., Div. 2 July 7, 2016) (unpublished), personal

Class Action Two-Fer: Class Counsel Fee Recovery Affirmed In Face Cream Class Action And Plaintiff Class Action Representative Suffers Adverse Fee Award Under The Consumers Legal Remedies Act For Bad Faith Prosecution

Cases: Class Actions, Cases: Consumer Statutes

  #1: Choi v. Mario Badescu Skin Care, Case No. B257480 (2d Dist., Div. 3 Apr. 29, 2016) (Unpublished).      Caption: “Testing cosmetics. Washington D.C. July 10, 1937. The department of Agriculture is making tests everyday in order to get cosmetics under the Pure Food and Drug Act, Mrs. C.W. West seated is helping Mrs.

Consumer Statutes/Deeds Of Trust: Where Borrower Was Granted Erroneous TRO Under Homeowner Bill Of Rights, $14,000 Fee Award Under Bill Of Rights Went POOF!

Cases: Consumer Statutes, Cases: Deeds of Trust, Cases: POOF!

  Predicate for Fee Entitlement Evaporated.      In our June 14, 2015 post, we discussed the Third District’s decision in Monterossa v. Superior Court, 237 Cal.App.4th 747, 754 (2015), which decided that attorney’s fees were properly awarded to a borrower obtaining a preliminary injunction against lender “dual tracking” under Civil Code section 2924.12(i) (the Homeowner

Scroll to Top