Cases: Section 1717

Choice of Law/Section 1717: Ninth Circuit, In Diversity Case, Affirms Fee Award Under Bank Loan Documents Even Though Georgia Choice-Of-Law Clause Involved

Cases: Choice of Law, Cases: Section 1717

  California Choice of Law Principles Governed, With Ninth Circuit Believing California Supreme Court Would Decide 1717 Evinces Fundamental State Policy.     In one of our early posts on June 11, 2008, we talked about Civil Code section 1717—which makes unilateral contractual fees clauses reciprocal in nature—and its interplay with choice of law decision—decisions considering […]

Costs, Prevailing Party, Section 1717: Plaintiff Tenants Obtaining CAM Credits And Monetary Settlement Were Prevailing Parties

Cases: Costs, Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Section 1717

  They Did Get $76,000 In Fees And $16,961 In Costs, But Not Anything More—Plaintiffs’ Behavior In Settlement Negotiations Found To Be Irrelevant For Fixing 1717 Fees.      Some of the gnarly cases involve those where there is no “unqualified winner” under Civil Code section 1717 as far as fees (although a winner for routine

Costs, Deeds Of Trust, Fee Clause Interpretation, Prevailing Party, Section 1717: Deed Of Trust Trustee Did Prevail Under Civil Code Section 1717 Where It Defensed Tort Claims And It Took Neutral Position On Contractual Claim Under Broadly Worded Fees Cla

Cases: Costs, Cases: Deeds of Trust, Cases: Fee Clause Interpretation, Cases: POOF!, Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Section 1717

  POOF!:  Award of Fees/Costs To Plaintiff Reversed, With Remand To Award Fees/Costs To Prevailing Trustee.      Torigian v. WT Capital Lender Services, Case No. F068393 (5th Dist. June 24, 2015) (unpublished) is an interesting unpublished decision, authored by Acting Presiding Justice Cornell, where a neutral trustee under a deed of trust was found to

Section 1717: Defendant Tenant Prevailing On Rent Control Ordinance/Rent Rate Declaratory Relief Claim Entitled To Fee Recovery

Cases: Landlord/Tenant, Cases: Section 1717

  Lower Court Erred In Refusing To Award Fees Under Fees Clause Which Encompassed Landlord’s Declaratory Relief Claim.      Earlier, tenant had won both trial and appellate court victories on the theory that landlord’s substantial rent increase violated local L.A. rent control ordinances, with landlord instigating things primarily through a declaratory relief-oriented action which landlord

Section 1717, Non-signatories, Special Fee Shifting Statutes: Nonsignatory Defendant Entitled To Fee Recovery Based On Statute Which Would Have Made Him Personally Liable For Signatory’s Obligations

Cases: Nonsignatories, Cases: Section 1717, Cases: Special Fee Shifting Statutes

  Impact of Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act Liability Considered By Appellate Panel.        Plaintiff (produce seller) sued a restaurant (Jack’s La Jolla) and its controlling officer Berkley to recover monies owed for the produce, claiming that Berkley had signed a guaranty and Berkley was subject to personal liability for restaurant’s contractual obligations (under an

Prevailing Party, Section 1717: Fee Clause Language Allowing Isolated Fee Recovery On Appellate Win Is Trumped By Section 1717’s Overall Prevailing Party Mandate

Cases: Prevailing Party, Cases: Section 1717

  Sixth District Rejects Notion that CCP § 1021 Prevails Over Civil Code § 1717.      This next case is interesting given that we have posted on some California unpublished decisions suggesting that fee entitlement is not at issue in Civil Code section 1717, with the provision only governing fairness and treatment of unilateral fee

Deed Of Trust, Section 1717: Plaintiff’s Post-Foreclosure Challenges To Sheriff’s Sale Was Not “On The Contract” For 1717 Fee Purposes

Cases: Deeds of Trust, Cases: Section 1717

  $63,120 Fee Award Reversed.      The Second District, Division 5, in Vega v. Goradia, Case No. B254585 (2d Dist., Div. 5 Feb. 26, 2015) (unpublished), confronted a $63,120 fee award to a prevailing defendant in an action brought by a plaintiff making certain post-foreclosure challenges to a sheriff’s sale (such as alleged notice of

Allocation, Section 1717: $1,047,250 Fee Recovery To Plaintiff Landlord Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Allocation, Cases: Section 1717

  Appellate Court Rejected Various Arguments that Fees Should Have Been Apportioned.      Plaintiff landlord won prevailing party fees under Civil Code section 1717, pursuant to a lease fees clause, against tenant Bank after plaintiff won compensatory damages of $1,016,812.50 after a two-phased trial (with the compensatory damages component subsequently settled out). Although initially requesting

Fee Clause Interpretation, Section 1717: Prevailing Alter Ego Entitled To Fee Recovery Based On Fee Clause Allowing For Same In A Payment Dispute

Cases: Fee Clause Interpretation, Cases: Section 1717

  Reynolds Metal Drove the Reversal.      Cooley Constr., Inc. v. Matthews, Case No. G050422 (4th Dist., Div. 3 Feb. 24, 2015) (unpublished) was a situation where an alter ego defendant prevailed against a plaintiff in a construction payment dispute, which had two fees clauses—one specifying no fees for construction disputes and another allowing recovery

Section 1717: Tenaciously Litigating Plaintiff Losing Case On Demurrer/Summary Judgment Properly Suffered Adverse Fee Award Of $254,886

Cases: Section 1717

  Fee Award Based on Settlement Agreement Fees Clause.      In Daria v. Level Studios, Inc., Case No. B249801 (2d Dist., Div. 6), the defense prevailed in a tenaciously litigated action brought by plaintiff where a trial court ultimately sustained a demurrer and then granted a summary judgment—with many claims dismissed based on releases in

Scroll to Top