Cases: Discovery

Discovery, Sanctions: $9,495 In Sanctions Against Client And Her Attorney For Failing To Reasonably Meet And Confer On Discovery Disputes Was Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Sanctions

Unpublished Opinion Has A Discussion On What Not To Do In The Meet And Confer Battles.                In Estate of Ambrose-Gordon, Case Nos. A169189 et al. (1st Dist., Div. 5 June 24, 2024) (unpublished), a probate litigant and her attorney were sanctioned $9,495 in discovery sanctions for failing to reasonably meet and confer with the […]

Discovery: 1/4 DCA Considers Some First Impression Issues Relating To Deposition Third-Party Subpoena Awards In Marital Dissolution Case

Cases: Discovery

60-Day Deadline To Compel Runs From Proper Service Of The Subpoena, No Separate Statement Absolutely Required If Motion Provides A Road Map, And Post-Motion Meet And Confer Discovery Efforts Are Not Compensable As A Cost In Bringing A Motion To Compel.                Marriage of Moore, Case No. A165038 (1st Dist., Div. 4 May 21, 2024)

Costs, Discovery: Court Of Appeal Found Nothing Wrong In Allowing Recovery Of Routine Costs For Filing Discovery Motions, Even If They Were Unsuccessful And Costs/Fees Were Denied Against Defendants In The Discovery Proceedings

Cases: Costs, Cases: Discovery

No Authority Shown To Conclude Otherwise, With Routine Costs And Actual Discovery Sanctions Serving Distinct Purposes.                In BBBB Bonding Corp. v. Pilling-Miller, Case Nos. H050703 et al. (6th Dist. May 10, 2024) (unpublished), plaintiff lost trade secret misappropriation and related claims, with costs of $34,989 out of a requested $44,989 awarded to the prevailing

Discovery, Sanctions: $10,000 Discovery Sanctions Against Clients’ Ex-Attorney Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Sanctions

Substitution Out Prior To Discovery Hearing Did Not Preclude The Sanctions Award, With Appealing Attorney Chided For Incivility.                Sometimes attorneys just need to “take their lumps” for discovery abuse, whether inspired by the client, counsel, or both to some degree.  Masimo Corp. v. The Vanderpool Law Firm, Inc., Case No. G061829 (4th Dist., Div.

Discovery, Sanctions: Where Litigant Mooted A Motion To Compel Against Third Party By Withdrawing The Motion, Discovery Sanctions Of $9,981 Were Reversed

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Sanctions

General Discovery Statutes Did Not Justify The Reversed Result, And The Absence Of An Order Did Not Support Sanctions Under CCP § 1987.2.             Although discovery sanctions are generally affirmed under an abuse of discretion standard, that is not always the case against third parties because different standards apply.             Agnone v. Agnone, Case

Discovery, Sanctions: Litigant’s Response To Document Requests Does Not Need To Specify Which Documents Are Responsive

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Sanctions

Discovery Sanctions Were Vacated, With Litigant Also Substantially Complying With Document Production Requirements.             Plaintiff and his counsel were sanctioned $910 for misusing the discovery process, in Pollock v. Superior Court (Schuster), Case No. B321229 (2d Dist., Div. 1 July 31, 2023) (published), because plaintiff failed to specify what documents were being produced in the

Discovery, Judgment Enforcement, Sanctions: Lower Court’s Failure To Include Discovery Sanctions In Post-Trial Judgment Was Not Erroneous

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Judgment Enforcement, Cases: Sanctions

Discovery Sanctions Was An Independent Monetary Judgment Subject to Post-Judgment Enforcement.             In Marriage of Bush, Case No. G061202 (4th Dist., Div. 3 June 15, 2023) (unpublished), a family law judge issued $3,635 in discovery sanctions against wife, but the judge stayed any payment until a trial determined who owed what.  However, the monetary sanction

Discovery, Family Law: Lower Court’ $68,358 Monetary Sanctions And Issue Sanction Against Ex-Husband For Failing To Produce QuickBooks Flash Drive To Wife’s Accounting Expert Was Sustained On Appeal

Cases: Discovery, Cases: Family Law

CCP § 2023.030 Allowed For The Award, With Willful Discovery Defiance Found By The Lower Court.             A party’s failure to comply with discovery orders can have harsh consequences:  monetary sanctions; issue sanctions; and sometimes even dismissal or directives to enter a default judgment.  Ex-husband found that out in Marriage of Foulk, Case No. C094350

Appealability, Discovery: Monetary Sanctions, Not Intertwined With Nonappealable Issue Sanctions Order, Can Be Entertained On Appeal

Cases: Appealability, Cases: Discovery

$37,575 Monetary Sanctions Against Defendants For Discovery Noncompliance Affirmed, Given Defense Conduct.             Bad facts can lead to published decisions which are not complementary to a party not conducting itself appropriately in litigation.  Defendants in Deck v. Developers Investment Co., Case No. G061287 (4th Dist., Div. 3 Mar. 24, 2023) (published) learned that sad reality.

Scroll to Top