Author name: Marc Alexander

Employment: $77,400 Labor Code Section 98.2 Fee Award Against Plaintiff Losing Labor Commissioner Appeal Affirmed On Appeal

Cases: Employment

  Section Allows Fee Recovery Against Either Losing Employee or Employer.     Labor Code section 98.2(c) is a two-way fee-shifting fee provision which mandates a lower court to award fees against either an employer or employee bringing an unsuccessful appeal from a Labor Commissioner ruling.  The legislative purpose of this section is to discourage meritless […]

Interpleader: Non-Neutral Party Causing Interpleader Filing, Rather Than Paying Judgment Or Posting Bond On Appeal, Properly Denied Fee Recovery Against Another Non-Neutral Party In Interpleader

Cases: Interpleader

  No Abuse Of Discretion In Deciding That Fees Paid To Discharged Interpleader Parties Did Not Have To Be Reimbursed By Other Non-Neutral Party.     Lender Currency makes high interest loans to songwriters obtaining royalty streams, while Wertheim, LLC obtains assignments of royalty rights and causes of action against Currency from the songwriters in return

Private Attorney General: Fee Award To Plaintiffs In State Water Board Proceeding Reversed Regarding Work On Prior Published Appeal

Cases: Private Attorney General (CCP 1021.5)

  Plaintiffs Failed To Satisfy Financial Burdens Elements of CCP § 1021 Analysis.     Plaintiffs successfully challenged a State Water Resources Control Board cease and desist order (CDO) in a water diversion case, which resulted in an affirmance in favor of plaintiffs in a prior published decision.  Based on that result, plaintiffs moved to recover

Deadlines/Family Law: New Trial Motion On Postjudgment Attorney’s Fees Denial To Wife Did Not Extend Period To Appeal

Cases: Deadlines, Cases: Family Law

  Wife’s Appeal Of Fee Denial Was Untimely.     Wife was flummoxed by a lower court’s refusal to award her attorney’s fees, appealing from the denial in Bennett v. Foss, Case Nos. A145656/147009 (1st Dist., Div. 1 Sept. 28, 2016) (unpublished).  Unfortunately for her, the appellate court determined that she untimely appealed such that it

Discovery: Discovery Into Amount And Source of Attorney’s Fees Not Privileged On Punitive Aspect Of Mining Claim Jumping Case

Cases: Discovery

  Requested Discovery Was Relevant To Discovery On Punitive Damages Financial Condition Where Trial Court Allowed Civil Code Section 3295 Discovery.     In Johnson v. Superior Court (Parker), Case No. C070028 (3d Dist. Sept. 28, 2016) (unpublished), the Third District denied the defendants’ mandate petition to prevent discovery of the amount and source of attorney’s

Section 1717: Voluntary Dismissal Under Santisas Cannot Be Overcome By Contrary Fee Entitlement Wording

Cases: Section 1717

  Plus, Sublease Fee Clause Failing To Incorporate Master Lease Broader Fee Provisions Also Required Denial Of Fee Request.     In Sancarrow Associates v. Hermanson, Case No. G051276 (4th Dist., Div. 3 Sept. 26, 2016) (unpublished), landlord voluntarily dismissed a contractually-oriented unlawful detainer complaint against sublessees, which prompted them to move to recovery contractual attorney’s

Costs: Contractual Fees Clause Also Allowing For Recovery Of Expert Witness Fees Enforced On Appeal

Cases: Costs

  Parties Can Indeed Negotiate Other Costs Besides Routine Costs As Being Recoverable In Their Contractual Agreements.     Porto Ramos-Pinto poster.  René Vincent.  ca 1925.       In Bel Vino, LLC v. Stuart, Case No. D069902 (4th Dist., Div. 1 Sept. 26, 2016) (unpublished), sellers of a winery (Stuart Cellars) in Temecula prevailed in a misrepresentation/contract

Allocation, Family Law, Substantiation Of Fees: Ex-Husband Failing To Allocate Between Recoverable And Non-Recoverable Claims During Trial Properly Denied Any Fees

Cases: Allocation, Cases: Family Law, Cases: Substantiation of Reasonableness of Fees

  Ex-Husband’s Failure To Allocate And Use Of Block Billing Resulted In Real Problems At Trial And Ultimate Denial Of Any Fees Incurred By Husband. Adding prize winner. Washington D.C. “In a speed and accuracy contest for adding machine operators last night, William A. Offutt of the Washington Loan and Trust Company, was declared winner

Reasonableness Of Fees: $61,901.25 Fee Award Affirmed Even Though Automobile Sales Finance Act Case Compensatory Award Only $30,035.84

Cases: Reasonableness of Fees

  Appellate Court Did Not Entertain New Arguments For Reductions Made On Appeal.       In the attorney’s fees area, you usually do not want to be in a position to solely challenge the amount of fees given a deferential abuse of discretion standard on appeal. That is where appellant went in Hammond v. Promenade Imports

Intellectual Property: Copyright Infringement Fees/Costs To Winner Almost Equaled Compensatory Infringement Verdict

Cases: Intellectual Property

  Prelitigation Destruction of Evidence May Have Pushed Case Over For Fee Recovery.      U.S. District Judge Larry R. Hicks (D. Nev.) recently awarded Oracle USA Inc. $46.2 million in costs and attorney’s fees under a copyright fee-shifting statute in a case where Oracle won a $50 million jury verdict against Rimini Street Inc. He

Scroll to Top