Substantiation Of Reasonableness Of Fees: $3,000 Discovery Sanctions Order Reversed And Remanded For A Lack Of Competent Substantiation

A Generalized Estimate Of Fees Expended On A Discovery Dispute Was Inadequate.

In Marriage of Pair, Case No. F089740 (5th Dist. Jan. 29, 2026) (unpublished), a $3,000 sanctions award against ex-wife and her counsel in a discovery dispute was reversed.  It was not reversed on the merits.  Instead, it was reversed and remanded because the $3,000 in incurred fees was based on a conclusory declaration statement about an estimate of what was expended by the winning side.  The Fifth District said not enough: too conclusory, with some explanation of hourly rates and an accounting of time expended to make sure it related to the discovery misuse issues.

Scroll to Top