Because Express Terms Of Contract Required Initialing To Create The Attorney Lien, No Lien Was Created.
In Tusken v. Rubin, Case No. B344909 (2d Dist., Div. 4 Nov. 18, 2026) (unpublished), attorney sought a declaratory judgment stating he had an attorney lien against proceeds recovered by his former client. Both the lower and appellate courts concluded that no valid attorney lien existed, because the attorney lien paragraph in the contingency retention agreement required initialing of the paragraph by both attorney and client and that was not done, so no attorney lien was created. Subjective intent was irrelevant, because the objective, unambiguous language of the contract required separate assent to the lien provision and subjective intent cannot contradict the objective language of the contract.
