Reasonableness Of Fees, Use Of Artificial Intelligence: Tenth Circuit Court Of Appeals Determines That Use Of AI Alone Will Not Establish A Fee Request As Unreasonable

Burden Is On The Opposing Party To Show Otherwise, Especially Given That The Need For AI Verification May Well Offset Any Billing Gains.

In a very pragmatic opinion, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals in Flux Drive Inc. v. Rong, 2026 WL 3266333 (10th Cir. Oct. 30, 2026) [published] faced the issue of whether fee claimant counsel’s use of AI during litigation, alone, means a fee request was unreasonable.  The appeals court answered no, offering guidance in this area on a first impression basis.

Defendants in a trade secret fight obtained dismissal on personal jurisdictional grounds, which triggered fee entitlement under Colorado and federal trade secret statutes.  The defense requested a lodestar of $183,653.61, awarded in full by the district judge and affirmed on appeal (given time billed in tenths of an hour, no block billing, reduced hours in certain areas, and absorption of extra work without inclusion in the request).

The Tenth Circuit concluded that using AI alone does not establish a fee request is unreasonable, with the burden on the opposing party to show otherwise.  But it went one step further: because of the need of fee claimant’s counsel to check the accuracy of AI use, that frequently will result in more work which well could eat up any savings.  The panel did leave open the possibility that AI use might reduce hours necessary to litigate the case, but the opposing party has the burden to so demonstrate. 

Scroll to Top